AA:
The guest is correct that we should analyse history objectively. However, he is focused on the events of Karbala and implying that events may not have happened as known, and that its commoration is causing fitna. He is absolutely wrong. Imam Gazzali has prohibited Karbala’s commemoration as he believed it brings about hatred for the sahabas.That is the real reason. How did yazeed (L)come to power. Why did abdullah ibn omer give him baya and not stand behind Imam Hussein (A).
It is a wonderful idea to study the events around Rasulallah (S) death, how he was prevented from writing his will, and accused of being mad, despite clear Quranic verses that cannot happen.One will get very surprising results. The killing of Rasulallah’s (S) entire family was the result of the actions of omar khattab.
AA:
The guest is correct that we should analyse history objectively. However, he is focused on the events of Karbala and implying that events may not have happened as known, and that its commoration is causing fitna. He is absolutely wrong. Imam Gazzali has prohibited Karbala’s commemoration as he believed it brings about hatred for the sahabas.That is the real reason. How did yazeed (L)come to power. Why did abdullah ibn omer give him baya and not stand behind Imam Hussein (A).
It is a wonderful idea to study the events around Rasulallah (S) death, how he was prevented from writing his will, and accused of being mad, despite clear Quranic verses that cannot happen.One will get very surprising results. The killing of Rasulallah’s (S) entire family was the result of the actions of omar khattab.