The Day of Ashura

6 تعليقات

  1. wait a minute

    what???????????????????

    i canot tell you how it hurts me to see my favourite thinker being censored and directed by a sectarian idiologue.

    • Sorry my brother I respect you as a Sunni muslim but talking this way, you seem like an ignorant.
      I think that you have to reconsider your admiration of the thinker Ramadan.. Do you have admiration regarding his strong ideas and his positions (i.e. the most important) or you focus (like a young child) only the « people » side of Mr Ramadan ?
      I think the most important is that you know that the reason, the dialogue is our only solution as muslim (Sunni or Shi’ah) to live together in peace and dignity.
      You are treating the Shia muslims as secterians but what do you think about the thousands Hadiths in the Sunni traditions where Shi’ah draw and defend their ideas and their positions about Islam, life and history of Islam ?
      I will be happy if you reconsider your position.

      I think that accuracy, thoroughness, sincerity and openness are important things that all humans must learn before starting the search for truth, any truth!
      Your shi’ah brothers can wait you more than one minute to let you know more about their philosophy… anyway it is good for our unity, as the brother Tariq has said.

    • I don’t see where Tariq is being censored and directed. For you to use the word sectarian shows that you are biaised.
      I think what Dr. Ramadan has done is great. He tried to build a bridge between Shiaa and Sunni Muslims. This cannot be achieved wihtout dialogue. I see a division even between Sunni Muslims here in Canada: between those born in Pakistan/Afghanistan and those of Egyptian origins, Lebanese, Somalis etc… we need to look beyond ou cultural differences. In the case of Shiaa and Sunni I don’t know what the answer is as I am not an expert.
      But wathever Tariq Ramadan is doing, i.e. bringing both parties at the table to have a dialoque, is certainly the best way.

  2. It is a real delight to see an open, civilized dialogue between scholars of both traditions.
    Misconceptions about eachother will only be resolved by open dialogue.
    We need enlightened scholars on both sides to come forward and bridge the gap and work together to unite Muslims.
    We are not sunni and Sh’ia, we are Muslims.
    And Thank you Dr Ramadan for your lectures, books, and everything you are doing for Islam in the west, you are truly inspirational.

  3. really liked the idea of negotiation which Mohammed Reza emphasized on in his dialogue. Imam Husain (as) left us Muslims a valuable message when he chose to resolve the conflict with peace.

  4. Many muslim leaders are traitors. Abbas, mubarak, karzai, maaliki, kings abdul & abdul, emirs of gulf…. A leader sacrifices for people, our arab/muslim leaders sacrifice muslims so they can stay in power. We are not persian, arabs, turks, kurds, sunni or shia. we are muslims.
    Muslim union is the only way out of ongoing ethnic cleansing of muslim civilians in many places like west bank, gaza, lebanon, iraq, chechnya, kashmir ….

ترك الرد

من فضلك ادخل تعليقك
من فضلك ادخل اسمك هنا